Tough Guys Don't Dance
The film Mailer wrote and directed from his 1984 novel, shot in Provincetown in the fall of 1986 for Cannon Films, with Ryan O'Neal and Isabella Rossellini; shown at Cannes in May 1987 and released on 18 September 1987 to mixed and negative reviews.

Tough Guys Don’t Dance is the film Mailer wrote and directed from his novel Tough Guys Don’t Dance (84.17), his fourth feature and the only one made for a commercial studio. Cannon Films financed it as part of the arrangement that also had Mailer write a script for Jean-Luc Godard’s King Lear (86.29). Menahem Golan and Yoram Globus produced, with Francis Ford Coppola and Tom Luddy as executive producers. Mailer wrote five drafts of the screenplay and, with Angelo Badalamenti, one of the film’s songs (87.2).
Filming began in Provincetown on 27 October 1986 and finished on 13 December (Lennon 2013, p. 621; 86.39). With a budget of $5 million and a crew of ninety-seven, Mailer brought the film in under budget and ahead of schedule (Lennon 2013, p. 622). Ryan O’Neal played Tim Madden, Debra Sandlund played Patty Lareine, and Lawrence Tierney played Dougy Madden; Isabella Rossellini co-starred. The Mailers’ own house at 627 Commercial Street stood in for Madden’s (86.37). John Bailey was the cinematographer (87.23). The reporters who came to the set found Mailer comparing the two crafts: “It took me two months to write the novel. The screenplay took six months” (86.38).
The film was shown at the Cannes Film Festival in May 1987, out of competition because Mailer was sitting on the jury. Vincent Canby praised it there as “a wonderfully exaggerated film noir story” (87.8; Lennon 2013, p. 624), though other early notices ran against it (87.7). After a New York premiere on 16 September, given with the Actors Studio at Loews New York Twin, it opened in New York and Los Angeles on 18 September 1987. Its reviewers included Canby in the New York Times, Pauline Kael in the New Yorker, Roger Ebert, Michael Wilmington in the Los Angeles Times and Hal Hinson in the Washington Post. With few exceptions the reviews were mixed or negative, and the box office was poor: the first weekend took in $421,390 (87.27), and the film eventually broke even (Lennon 2013, p. 627).
The film was nominated for Golden Raspberry Awards in seven categories, Mailer tying with Elaine May for worst director, and for Independent Spirit Awards in four, best film among them. It was the end of his career as a director; it later became a minor cult classic (Lennon 2013, pp. 627–28).
Mailer gave some forty interviews about the film between the shoot and the release (86.29–88.12). The fullest are David Thompson’s “Mailer by the Bay” (87.10b), which ranges over all his films, and Karen Jaehne’s “Mailer’s Minuet” (87.28) in Film Comment. The film runs 109 minutes.
Related pages
- Tough Guys Don’t Dance (84.17), the novel
- “Mailer by the Bay” (87.10b) | “Mailer’s Minuet” (87.28) | HFPA interview (87.23a)
- Wild 90 | Beyond the Law | Maidstone
- Cannon Films | Ryan O'Neal | Provincetown, Massachusetts | The Actors Studio
- 1986 | 1987
Criticism 12
Reviews
- Wilmington, Michael. “Movie Review: Mailer's Tough Guys Don't Dance.” Los Angeles Times, 1987-09-17, 1. register
- Canby, Vincent. “Film: Norman Mailer's Tough Guys Don't Dance.” New York Times, 1987-09-18, C14. register
- Ebert, Roger. “Tough Guys Don't Dance.” Chicago Sun-Times, 1987-09-18. register
- Hinson, Hal. “Tough Guys Don't Dance.” Washington Post, 1987-09-18. register
- Kael, Pauline. “Temporary Madnesses: Forster, Mailer, Hepburn.” New Yorker, 1987-09-21. register
Essays, chapters, and books
- Manon, Hugh S. “Heading Off Satisfaction in Tough Guys Don't Dance.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
- Morrow, Stephan. “Tough Guys Do Dance.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
- Duguid, Scott. “Tough Guys Don't Dance and the Cinema of Reaganism.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 273–286. register
- Ryan, James Emmett. “Pulp Fiction in Provincetown.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 245–258. register
- Ventura, Michael. “Dance of a Tough Guy.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 235–244. register
- Bozung, Justin. “Film.” Norman Mailer in Context, Cambridge University Press, 2021-08-26, 91–101. register
- Adlerberg, Scott. “50 Years Later, Reconsidering Norman Mailer's Wild, Bloody Provincetown Noir.” CrimeReads, 2026-06-15. register