Norman Mailer: Works and Days A digital bio-bibliography

Beyond the Law

Mailer's second feature film: a night in a New York police station, improvised by its actors, with Mailer as Lieutenant Francis Xavier Pope. First shown, unfinished, at Notre Dame on 2 April 1968, and at the New York Film Festival that September.

Norman Mailer as Lt. Francis Xavier Pope in Beyond the Law (1967)

Beyond the Law is Mailer’s second feature film, begun in early October 1967 and first called Bust 80. It follows a weekend night in a Manhattan precinct station, where Lieutenant Francis Xavier Pope of the vice squad (Mailer, with an Irish brogue) and his detectives work over the night’s arrests (Lennon 2013, pp. 379–80; Mills 1982, pp. 310–11). The idea came from Mailer’s own interrogation at a West 100th Street station house in 1960 (Lennon 2013, p. 376). “Beyond the Law is a picture about a police station,” he said; what interested him was what happens to a man arrested for the first time (69.5). Like Wild 90 it was shot over four nights with no script, the actors given an identity and told to improvise, but now with three camera crews working at once in different parts of the building. It was filmed in 16mm, black and white, with hand-held cameras (68.5).

Mickey Knox and Buzz Farbar play Pope’s detectives, Beverly Bentley his wife, and George Plimpton the mayor, who comes to inspect the precinct. Rip Torn and Michael McClure are Hells Angels, Jack Richardson a gambler, and Eddie Bonetti an ax murderer; José Torres, Marsha Mason, Lee Roscoe, Noel Parmentel and Harold Conrad are also in the cast (Lennon 2013, p. 380). D. A. Pennebaker, Nick Proferes and Jan Welt photographed it; Welt, Lana Jokel and Mailer edited it; Farbar and Mailer produced it for Supreme Mix (Scholastic, 29 March 1968, pp. 24–25), and Mailer put up the money (Lennon 2013, p. 379).

Mailer spent nearly eight months editing eleven hours of footage down to 110 minutes (Lennon 2013, pp. 381, 398–99). The film had its first showing on Tuesday 2 April 1968 in the Stepan Center at Notre Dame, during the university’s literary festival, before an audience of 3,500. It was not finished: in remarks printed beforehand in the Scholastic (“Beyond the Law,” 68.5) Mailer warned that it had no titles, no credits and no music. The evening was reported in the Chicago papers (68.6b, 68.6d).

The finished film was shown at the New York Film Festival, in Philharmonic Hall, on 28 September 1968, where a good many of the audience walked out (Lennon 2013, p. 399). Vincent Canby, reviewing it for the New York Times, found it “good and tough and entertaining.” It opened at the Art Theater in New York on 23 October, and Canby interviewed Mailer about it that week (“When Irish Eyes Are Smiling, It’s Norman Mailer,” 68.26). Roger Ebert reviewed it in Chicago the next year. Mailer sold the distribution rights to Barney Rosset of Grove Press for $15,000 and later bought the film back (Mills 1982, p. 326). It lost more than $70,000, though it went on finding audiences on the college circuit (Lennon 2013, p. 399).

He kept showing it: at Western Illinois University in 1972, where he first met J. Michael Lennon (72.19), and at the Thalia in New York in January 1984, with Maidstone (84.1). The restoration in Maidstone and Other Films by Norman Mailer (Criterion Collection, 2012) runs 97 minutes.

Criticism 12

Reviews

  • Canby, Vincent. “Norman Mailer Offers Beyond the Law.” New York Times, 1968-09-30. register
  • Byro. “Beyond the Law.” Variety, 1968-10-02, 24. register
  • Sarris, Andrew. “Films: Beyond the Law.” Village Voice, 1968-10-24. register
  • Kauffmann, Stanley. “Beatles and Other Creatures.” The New Republic, 1968-11-16, 18, 32. register
  • Ebert, Roger. “Beyond the Law.” Chicago Sun-Times, 1969-11-04. register

Essays, chapters, and books

  • Knox, Mickey. The Good, the Bad, and the Dolce Vita: The Adventures of an Actor in Hollywood, Paris, and Rome. New York: Nation Books, 2004. register
  • Cohen, Sara Jo. “Making Masculinity and Unmaking Jewishness: Norman Mailer's Voice in Wild 90 and Beyond the Law.” The Mailer Review, 2011. register
  • Brody, Richard. “Norman Mailer at the Movies.” New Yorker, 2013-10-30. register
  • Singer, Robert. “Defective Detectives: Generic Tension in Beyond the Law.” The Mailer Review, 2017. register
  • Jurkiewicz, Kenneth. “Transcending the Formula: Beyond the Law and the Old-Fashioned Cop Movie.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 79–108. register
  • McAvoy, Catriona. “All of us are Policeman, All of us are Criminals': Discovering Dostoevsky in a Re-evaluation of Beyond the Law.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 109–118. register
  • Bozung, Justin. “Film.” Norman Mailer in Context, Cambridge University Press, 2021-08-26, 91–101. register

First published: 1968-04-02
Form: film
Cite as: /works/1968-04-beyond-the-law
Last updated: 2026-11-12