Norman Mailer: Works and Days A digital bio-bibliography

Maidstone

Mailer's third feature film, shot over five days in the Hamptons in July 1968, with Mailer as Norman T. Kingsley, a film director who may run for President; it ends with Rip Torn's unscripted hammer attack. An early version was shown in 1970; the American premiere was at the Whitney Museum on 22 September 1971.

Norman Mailer as Norman T. Kingsley in Maidstone

Maidstone is the third of Mailer’s films, the last of the three he made in the 1960s and much the largest. He conceived it in the days after the murder of Robert Kennedy in June 1968, and its subject is assassination (Lennon 2013, p. 400; 72.5). Mailer plays Norman T. Kingsley, a famous and infamous film director who has come to an estate on Long Island to cast a film about a male brothel, and who is one of fifty men the country might consider for President. A secret police agency guards him, though some of its men seem as ready to kill him as to protect him. Rip Torn plays Raoul Rey O’Houlihan, Kingsley’s half-brother, who may be loyal or may be the assassin (Lennon 2013, pp. 400–401).

There was again no script, only a situation. Five camera crews, with D. A. Pennebaker, Nick Proferes, Jan Welt and Richard Leacock among the cameramen, filmed for five days in late July 1968 on four estates in and around East Hampton, in colour, with hand-held cameras. The cast of fifty to sixty included Beverly Bentley as Kingsley’s estranged wife, Lady Jeanne Campbell as a British television reporter, Buzz Farbar, Eddie Bonetti, Carol Stevens, José Torres, Michael McClure, Barney Rosset and Robert F. Lucid (Lennon 2013, p. 401). To pay for it Mailer sold most of his stock in the Village Voice (Mills 1982, p. 326). He produced it with Farbar for Supreme Mix, with Leo Garen as associate producer.

The shoot was violent. At a party scene Mailer broke an actor’s jaw (68.16). On the last day, when most of the cast and crews had gone, Mailer and Beverly were walking with four of their children across a field on Gardiners Island while Pennebaker filmed them. Torn ran at them with a hammer and struck Mailer on the head, saying that Kingsley must die, not Mailer; the two wrestled on the ground and Mailer bit Torn’s ear. Mailer told Torn he would cut the scene. Watching the forty-five hours of footage over the next year, he found little of it usable and concluded that Torn had been right to attack, and the fight became the film’s ending (Lennon 2013, pp. 402–3). J. Anthony Lukas reported the shoot for the New York Times (68.14, 68.16); the longer accounts are Sally Beauman’s in New York (68.17) and James Toback’s in Esquire (“At Play in the Fields of the Bored,” 68.28).

Invitation to the New York premiere of Maidstone, Whitney Museum, 22 September 1971

Mailer edited the film for three years, with Jan Welt and Lana Jokel. An early version was shown in Provincetown on 24 August 1970 and at the Venice Film Festival on 30 August (70.12), and two months later at the London Film Festival, where Mailer traded jabs with a restless audience (70.13). Stung, he re-edited it. The American premiere was at the Whitney Museum on 22 September 1971, opening the second season of the museum’s New American Filmmakers Series. It drew seven thousand people there, a record for the museum, and failed when it was shown commercially the next month (Lennon 2013, p. 404). Vincent Canby reviewed it in the New York Times, and Jay Cocks in Time (“Norman’s Phantasmagoria,” 71.30).

The published text, Maidstone: A Mystery (71.28), followed on 1 October 1971, with the screenplay, a combined account of the filming, and “A Course in Film-Making” (71.25), Mailer’s fullest essay on film.

Mailer took the film to campuses in 1971 and 1972 (71.15a, 72.2, 72.3, 72.4, 72.5). He showed it again in Boston in 1982 (82.20, 82.21) and at the Thalia in New York in 1984, when he called it “a terribly flawed and imperfect movie that’s really interesting for people who are obsessed by film” (84.1). His last public appearance, on 22 July 2007, was at a showing of it at Lincoln Center (07.37). He called it “my failed cinematic masterpiece” (Lennon 2013, p. 404).

The release ran 110 minutes; the restoration that gives Maidstone and Other Films by Norman Mailer (Criterion Collection, 2012) its title runs 105.

Criticism 18

Reviews

  • Canby, Vincent. “Film: Mailer's Maidstone Opens Whitney Series.” New York Times, 1971-09-24, 31. register
  • Canby, Vincent. “Norman Mailer—An Ego to Cherish.” New York Times, 1971-09-26, D1, D5. register
  • Weales, Gerald. “Mailer's Maidstone.” North American Review, 1972, 62–64. register

Essays, chapters, and books

  • Schickel, Richard. “Stars and Celebrities.” Commentary, 1971-08, 61–65. register
  • [unsigned]. “Mailer Opening.” New Yorker, 1971-10-02, 33. register
  • Braudy, Leo. “Maidstone: A Mystery by Norman Mailer.” Native Informant: Essays on Film, Fiction and Popular Culture, Oxford, 1991, 60–63, 145–151. register
  • Howard, Gerald. “Mailer Gets Hammered.” New York Times Book Review, 2007-08-26, 27. register
  • Chaiken, Michael. “Editing Mailer: A Conversation with Jan Welt and Lana Jokel.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
  • Kramer, Daniel. “Mailer, Maidstone, and Me.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
  • Steiner, Griselda. “Maidstone: A Sign of the Times.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
  • Bernstein, Mashey. “Maidstone, Mailer, and Mashey: A Night at the Movies.” The Mailer Review, 2009. register
  • Dollar, Steve. “A Long Island Horror Story.” Wall Street Journal Abstracts, 2012-08-29. register
  • Bishop, Sarah. “The Life and Death of the Celebrity Author in Maidstone.” The Mailer Review, 2012. register
  • Brody, Richard. “Norman Mailer at the Movies.” New Yorker, 2013-10-30. register
  • Bishop, Sarah. “The Life and Death of the Celebrity Author in Maidstone.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 145–160. register
  • D'Amico, John. “Maidstone: The Unilinear Abstract.” The Cinema of Norman Mailer: Film is Like Death, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 161–166. register
  • Whiteway, John. “Photos from Maidstone.” Norman Mailer Society, 2021-01-05. register
  • Bozung, Justin. “Film.” Norman Mailer in Context, Cambridge University Press, 2021-08-26, 91–101. register

First published: 1970-08
Form: film
Cite as: /works/1970-08-maidstone
Last updated: 2026-11-12