Introduction
Norman Mailer's Provincetown: The Wild West of the East · Provincetown Arts Press, 2005
1In August of 1960 Norman Mailer drove from his summer home in Provincetown to the summer home of Senator John Kennedy in Hyannis. Kennedy was seeking the Democratic nomination for president, and Mailer was there to interview him for Esquire. It was a heady time for Mailer, who was impressed when Kennedy said he had read Mailer’s third novel, The Deer Park. The piece that Mailer wrote about Kennedy, “Superman Comes to the Supermarket,” appeared a few weeks before the election and certainly aided Kennedy’s successful campaign. Mailer met Jacqueline Kennedy that memorable day, and she asked him what Provincetown was like. “It is the Wild West of the East,” he replied. Mailer has emphasized the quirky energy and unpredictability of Provincetown, or P-Town, as the locals call it, many times over the years—in interviews, essays, letters, casual conversation, and in several of his published works. He has also called it “the last democratic town in America. Everybody is absolutely equal here.” Now Mailer’s permanent home, P-Town is where he has spent 45 of the last 60 summers, and written all or part of three-fourths of his 40-odd books. Here are just a few of his insights on the town at the end of Route 6: In a Boston Globe interview (June 22, 2003) with Joseph P. Kahn, Mailer said that during the summers of the early ’60s “bikers would come roaring into town on Saturday nights. Parties would start on the beach. Fights would break out. It was a period of wonderful drunken nights and wild parties. At least 10 times a summer you’d see the sun come up over the flats. The town had a sometimes rich and sometimes sinister sense of impermanence to it, too.”
In an interview in Life in Provincetown (August 14, 2003) with Tim McCarthy, he expanded on the idea of P-Town’s mutability: “The bars would empty at midnight, because that was the curfew then. Everyone who was working at the bars, everyone who was going to the bars would head up in the hills behind the Patrician. Howland Street didn’t exist then. It was a trail up into the woods. There were a few shacks up there as there are now, and guys who had the shacks would open them up and people would come in. You’d find a mother who couldn’t get a babysitter come in with two kids, holding one in each arm. You’d have drinkers like myself, who’d hold a bottle in one hand and a glare in their eye… . You had marriages break up in those woods at night around two or three in the morning. You had marriages begin. It was wild, absolutely wild. There were fights. It was an absolutely extraordinary period.” Provincetown’s “purpose,” he continued, is to “be the one town on the Atlantic coast that’s just absolutely freer than others, where people can go and find out what they’re really made of, because they can’t quite find organized society agreeable enough to keep going. They want to search out the possibility of being themselves, whatever that self is… . Years ago it was bikers and guys who were really part-time criminals, drug dealers, gamblers. Then there was a period after that when the gay revolution began and then solidified in the last 10 or 15 years. So today Provincetown’s a gay town, but so what? … In the next 25, 30, 40 years, it will become something else again.” It would not be difficult to point to a dozen other utterances in which Mailer identifies Provincetown as a 2fiercely independent, slightly nutty town, a carnival, a whirligig where identities are lost, found, created.
There is more: In a 1999 interview with Christopher Busa in Provincetown Arts, Mailer goes beyond his characterization of Provincetown as the freest on the Atlantic coast. He says, “Provincetown has always been ahead of the rest of the nation. One of the things I love about this town and that I always tell people who haven’t been here, is that this is the freest town in America. People can argue. But it’s free now with the gay population, and it was free long ago when the artists came here. You could live with whomever you wanted and in any combination that you wanted. To have sexual freedom has always been terribly important to artists.” The artists and writers—John Dos Passos, Eugene O’Neill, Kurt Vonnegut, Hans Hofmann, Mary McCarthy, Robert Motherwell, Jack Kearney, Franz Kline, Peter Busa, and Helen Frankenthaler are some of those he mentions in these interviews—relished the freedom of the town, but through the 1960s they had to contend with what Mailer calls “an ongoing tension” with the Portuguese, who dominated the fishing industry and much else in the town. On the one hand, he says, “Some of the Portuguese fishermen were wilder and stronger than any artist you’d ever find. We’d get drunk together and have arm-wrestling contests, often. I remember Bottles Souza was the one guy nobody could ever beat.” On the other hand, “the Portuguese were Catholic and observant and very family-oriented, prodigiously family oriented, and the artists came every summer with a different mate, sometimes a different kid. Of course, we were smoking pot. It was all right to get drunk in town—but not pot. That was the tension then.”
Finally, he gives a cluster of assets that fills out his portrait of the town: “The fishermen were much respected in those days, and properly so—they were real, and artists tend to have a tropism toward the real. Provincetown was not only most agreeable to the eye, but it was real, with real people. It had been a whaling town. It was real enough that when the Pilgrims came here, they decided to move on because it was a little bit too real.”
There’s no easy way to sum up all that Mailer has said about P-Town, especially since in my gleanings I have scanted Mailer’s comments on the town’s beauty, noted in passing in the previous quote as “agreeable.” The best course is to turn to the sharp evocations of the town in his writings, but first I’ll name what I believe to be the five ineluctable elements of his unstated definition of the town: 1) freedom (personal, artistic, sexual); 2) mutability (of an existential sort); 3) tension (historical, cultural, creative); 4) beauty (natural and architectural); and 5) a haunted atmosphere, amenable to ghosts and witches. These qualities can be seen in the four chief depictions of Provincetown in Mailer’s work from 1958 to 1984. The first is from “Advertisements for Myself on the Way Out,” a story that originally appeared in Partisan Review in 1958, and then was collected in Advertisements for Myself (1959). It was intended to be the prologue to a long novel, one never written. The house in the story belongs to the central character, Marion Faye, and is based on the former Hawthorne house Mailer lived in at the top of Miller Hill Road. In the ’50s it was the only house there; there are a dozen or more there now.